Justia Copyright Opinion Summaries

A graphic designer was commissioned in 2016 to create a room-sized artwork for a brewery’s exhibition at an annual fair produced by the defendant. The agreement specified that the designer would retain copyright ownership and that the installation could only be shown in person to paying patrons at the 2016 event. During the fair, the defendant created and widely disseminated marketing videos online featuring the designer’s work without attribution, despite the designer’s requests for credit. The designer applied for copyright registration in April 2017, and the work was eventually registered, though the exact date of registration is not in the record.The designer first filed a pro se copyright infringement suit in the United States District Court for the District of Massachusetts in early 2018, but the court dismissed it without prejudice for failure to allege copyright registration. Instead of amending, the designer filed a second action in state court, which was removed to federal court. After amending her complaint, the district court again dismissed the copyright claims, this time with prejudice, for failure to state a plausible claim and failure to allege registration. The designer did not respond to the motion to dismiss. In December 2020, now represented by counsel, she filed the present suit in federal court, which was dismissed with prejudice on claim preclusion grounds. On appeal, the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit reversed and remanded for further consideration.On remand, the district court again dismissed the case, this time on both claim preclusion and statute of limitations grounds. The United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit affirmed the dismissal, holding that the copyright infringement claims were untimely under the three-year statute of limitations, as the plaintiff knew or should have known of the alleged infringement by early 2017. The court also found no basis for equitable tolling. View "Foss v. Eastern States Exposition" on Justia Law